1919 A4 Forums banner

Medium level DD cannons

1270 Views 29 Replies 15 Participants Last post by  BeltFedEd
Guess I better move the discussion to the medium level DD cannons. As I have stated before I am no expert but I am reasonably knowledgeable on the subject. Just passing on a few things I have learned over the years. I consider these medium difficulty for multiple reasons. Also note medium level DD’s are a quite difficult to deal with for various reasons. Also not talking about onesies twosie guns.

First the PAK 36. With German guns the prefix PAK is short for Panzerabwehrkanone. (Anti tank gun) The US we use “pack” in reference to guns we can pack by mule or man power. Now the PAK 36 is a German 37mm. Is is the German equivalent to the US 37 or bofors. Could almost fall in to the easy category. It is a lot rarer than both and more “complex” some people might use the term over engineered. It fires the 37x297R German case. Also a pretty rare case. Some are chambered in the 37mm bofors. No spare parts, rare, hard to work on. Can use super slow powder, custom primers, and projectiles must be made.

Next we are going with the US pack 75. The pack 75 is a howitzer not a cannon. For the non cannon cockers, howitzers are designed for indirect lobbing of high explosive projectiles. Where cannons are designed for direct fire. The Pack 75 is really cool because it can be broken down by two “strong” people and transported in a big car or van. It was adopted in 1927 with wooden spoke wheels and still officially in the US inventory. We gave some to Chinese during WW2 that were later donated to the Viet Cong and used against us in Viêt Nam. Cases are super cheap and plentiful. They use the common US artillery primer and can still use super slow powder. Optics are easy. Projectiles are getting harder to find and expensive. Can also be cast out zinc or possibly lead with its lower velocity. Obviously casting this size is not easy and pretty dangerous. There is a huge demand for these guns from the military vehicle types. They look great behind a jeep. This has really driven the prices up. The guns are pretty basic with a manually operated breach. Spare parts are out there but getting expensive. Lobs a 12 pound projo at max 1200 fps. Most shooters load them a little lighter. Not a lot of bang for your buck.

Next we have a real banger. The US 57mm. The US 57mm M1 was our main cannon of WW2. It is a 3500 pound gun that will lift its tires off the ground when fired. It is a potent gun and a lot of bang for the buck. It is built tough, durable, simple. Semi automatic falling block (block automatically drops and ejects a case when fired) Most of the scope mounts have been removed from the gun so optics are tricky. For ammunition there are drill rounds available. The drill rounds do not contain powder but the cases are usable and the projectiles are legit AP. Primers are a problem and must be manufactured for the drill round cases. Original cases use the standard US artillery primer. Also powder is an issue. Once we get in to the bigger grain powder needed for bigger guns it is unavailable unless you have an explosive license or have a buddy with a license. The gun is highly desirable from the military vehicle group as well.

T124 76mm. Thé T124 was built in the 1950’s with all of our knowledge from WW2. It was the pinnacle of our wheeled cannon development. Light weight, powerful, well balanced. Semi automatic breach. Never formally adopted as it was replaced by much lighter recoilless rifles. Only about 100 guns built. Because it was never adopted most of the guns stayed in country and pop up more regularity than you would expect. Main Gun was repurposed for the walker bulldog tank. Cases are available and projectiles are one of the most common 76mm projectiles available. Easily identified by one large driving band and 2 smaller bands. Uses a unique primer assembly that must be manufactured. Powder is a problem like the 57mm. Don’t even ask about original optics. It weighs about the same as the US 57 but the cases uses more than twice the powder and double the projectile weight. The blast from firing this gun is insane. It reeks havoc on everything around it including the shooter. Not all that desirable by collectors but probably one of the best big guns as far as bang for the buck.

105mm howitzer M101 The WW2 US 105. Another US workhorse. In service from 1941 to now. Big heavy gun at 5000 pounds. Not all that easy to set up or move around but way easier than the later m102 105. Uses a manually operated sliding breach block. Cases are super common and cheap can find them at almost any gun show on a random table. Primers are easy US artillery primer. Even the powder is available as it can use Super slow powder. Optics are common as well. Projectiles are becoming a problem and will have to be sorted if you plan on shooting a lot. Relatively low velocity as it lobs a 20 pound projo at max 1500. Can fire directly or indirect. Highly desirable by military vehicle crowd. As a shooter, it is in my opinion soso. Uses about the same amount of powder as the 57mm but a much larger projectile. Very efficient no huge muzzle blast or gun dynamics. Good for actual combat but not a show stopper.

Some other guns that fall in the medium category but are so rare they never pop up
I can answer specific questions if anyone has any. PAK 40, ZIS 3, US 3” Army, m102 105, PAK 38, 2 pounder British. etc.

Most of these medium could be set up
And fired buy one highly motivated and strong person but generally need a crew of 2 or more. 3 or 4 on the 76’s and 105. They are big and require heavy equipment to work on. 76mm guns won’t fit in a one car garage. Can be a problem to transport and store with an average SOT.






Jeans Water Leisure Travel Landscape
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 5
1 - 20 of 30 Posts
really enjoying these Bob, keep up the good work.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
really enjoying these Bob, keep up the good work.
Thanks man got a few more in the que
  • Like
  • Helpful
Reactions: 3
Hey Bob. How is the current situation for powder supply. I know for the bigger stuff you need the FEL to get it. But are the manufacturers selling it to "civilian" FELs? I thought I heard a while back they'll powder was getting hard to find, but that may have been for non-FEL shooters
Hey Bob. How is the current situation for powder supply. I know for the bigger stuff you need the FEL to get it. But are the manufacturers selling it to "civilian" FELs? I thought I heard a while back they'll powder was getting hard to find, but that may have been for non-FEL shooters
Truthfully powder is better now than it has ever been. We have a large enough variety and quantity
to shoot everything from the puteaux to the 8”. The Explosive license is a pain in the ass but most of the shooters realize it is just one more thing to deal with and figure out a solution. Really, it is better to have to deal with the license and have access to tons of powder than it was to not have the license and always on the hunt for any quantity of powder that we could make work.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Truthfully powder is better now than it has ever been. We have a large enough variety and quantity
to shoot everything from the puteaux to the 8”. The Explosive license is a pain in the ass but most of the shooters realize it is just one more thing to deal with and figure out a solution. Really, it is better to have to deal with the license and have access to tons of powder than it was to not have the license and always on the hunt for any quantity of powder that we could make work.
What does your average guy do with storing powder? Just reloading MGs, I feel like has to much powder laying around, I can only imagine how much powder you guys are storing at times.

I am really looking forward to the Large level DD Cannons post! I want to see these 8" guns you are talking about. Anyone have a battleship level gun? (11"+)
What does your average guy do with storing powder? Just reloading MGs, I feel like has to much powder laying around, I can only imagine how much powder you guys are storing at times.

I am really looking forward to the Large level DD Cannons post! I want to see these 8" guns you are talking about. Anyone have a battleship level gun? (11"+)
Because most of the powder is considered low explosive it gets stored in explosive magazines. Type 4 low magazines are pretty easy and can be made using a conex box. The funny thing is the bigger grain cannon powder is far safer than standard reloading powders. It takes substantially more spark to ignite and burns much slower. Have ignited full 150 pound drums to see what would happen and you get about 5 seconds of what sounds like a jet engine then out. Be really curious to see what a full drum of bullseye would do. No battleship level guns yet. Logistics are a whole new level
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Between the fireworks forums and the BATF’s Orange Book (get a copy free from them) you can figure out magazine/storage requirements. Just have to check all the boxes.
Really loving these thread series, Bob. Really looking forward to the next one. Thanks for posting them here.
Great series! Excited for the next ones
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Great information! What ever happened to James DeGroat IIRC he had a showstopper or 2 I believe was a 90mm? Ahh the days gone by..
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Great information! What ever happened to James DeGroat IIRC he had a showstopper or 2 I believe was a 90mm? Ahh the days gone by..
James is still around. I sold him that 90mm way back in the day. Kinda how we became friends. That gun will always be one of my biggest regrets. It was a really cool gun and I had a lot of components for it. Literally tons of components. Now it is siting in a private museum probably never to be shot again.
  • Sad
Reactions: 1
@Dangerous Bob,
For the smaller DDs and these, what is the approx cost of componets? A barrel of slow powder is $ and how much per charge? Just wondering, ballpark, the cost per loaded round for each size.
@Dangerous Bob,
For the smaller DDs and these, what is the approx cost of componets? A barrel of slow power is $ and how much per charge? Just wondering, ballpark, the cost per loaded round for each size.
That is one of the most frequent questions I get. Also, one of the hardest to answer. Components can very drastically in price. Let’s talk about one of the extremes in the 75mm pack howitzer. Cases are easy to find and cheap running 15-40 a piece. Life span on a pack howitzer case in probably indefinitely as long as you take care of it. The primer assembly dose have a life span of 5 or 6 reloads. Some more some less. Let’s say a US made primer assembly is $10 each. They are reloaded with a 50 primer and a minimal amount of black powder. Original collector projectiles can run 100’s of dollars the ugly shooter projectiles can cost 40-75 each give or take. Now casting out of zinc can be cheaper but don’t forget the 1000’s you will spend on casting equipment. You can buy expensive casting zinc or get a bunch of scraps for next to nothing. We will put a $40 estimate on casting zinc projectiles. Powder can cost 20 a pound if you buy a 8 pound jug or $8 a pound if you buy a ton. The 75 uses 1/2 pound a shot. So realistically it can cost anywhere from about $40 a shot to 140 a shot. A 25mm puteaux using reloaded ammunition can cost 15-40 a piece. Cannons can actually be pretty inexpensive to shoot. unfortunately the only way to make them inexpensive to shoot involves spending a lot of money in quantity component purchases, reload equipment, and tooling. For the guy that shoots once a year it will be on the upper end of the prices for the guy that shoots 100 rounds of puteaux in one sitting it can get pretty inexpensive per round
See less See more
  • Like
  • Helpful
Reactions: 4
That is one of the most frequent questions I get. Also, one of the hardest to answer. Components can very drastically in price. Let’s talk about one of the extremes in the 75mm pack howitzer. Cases are easy to find and cheap running 15-40 a piece. Life span on a pack howitzer case in probably indefinitely as long as you take care of it. The primer assembly dose have a life span of 5 or 6 reloads. Some more some less. Let’s say a US made primer assembly is $10 each. They are reloaded with a 50 primer and a minimal amount of black powder. Original collector projectiles can run 100’s of dollars the ugly shooter projectiles can cost 40-75 each give or take. Now casting out of zinc can be cheaper but don’t forget the 1000’s you will spend on casting equipment. You can buy expensive casting zinc or get a bunch of scraps for next to nothing. We will put a $40 estimate on casting zinc projectiles. Powder can cost 20 a pound if you buy a 8 pound jug or $8 a pound if you buy a ton. The 75 uses 1/2 pound a shot. So realistically it can cost anywhere from about $40 a shot to 140 a shot. A 25mm puteaux using reloaded ammunition can cost 15-40 a piece. Cannons can actually be pretty inexpensive to shoot. unfortunately the only way to make them inexpensive to shoot involves spending a lot of money in quantity component purchases, reload equipment, and tooling. For the guy that shoots once a year it will be on the upper end of the prices for the guy that shoots 100 rounds of puteaux in one sitting it can get pretty inexpensive per round

Ive always wondered, what do the seating and sizing dies look like for cannon brass and where do you source those? or is it one of those things where you are hand sizing and and trimming?
Water Wheel Cannon Sky Plant


We have a papered live reactivated German PAK40 but currently only fire hot blanks. I can load, transport and unload unassisted using a winch mounted on my trailer deck but otherwise its a beast to try and move by hand on anything other than flat concrete. Have two blank firing systems with one utilizing U.S. 75 pack howitzer cases and the other using original German PAK40 cases with a modified reloadable primer design that would equally work with firing a projectile. Haven't rebuilt the recoil buffers yet but everything else has been a ground up restoration.
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 5
View attachment 129922

We have a papered live reactivated German PAK40 but currently only fire hot blanks. I can load, transport and unload unassisted using a winch mounted on my trailer deck but otherwise its a beast to try and move by hand on anything other than flat concrete. Have two blank firing systems with one utilizing U.S. 75 pack howitzer cases and the other using original German PAK40 cases with a modified reloadable primer design that would equally work with firing a projectile. Haven't rebuilt the recoil buffers yet but everything else has been a ground up restoration.
that is awesome man. You will have all kinds of fun with that recoil system. Good luck. I look forward to seing a second live firing PAK 40.
  • Like
Reactions: 2
Ive always wondered, what do the seating and sizing dies look like for cannon brass and where do you source those? or is it one of those things where you are hand sizing and and trimming?
Usually completely custom. Typically it is a 3 die set. One that sizes the body. A second due for neck and a 3rd for the case mouth
1 - 20 of 30 Posts
Top